Dependency Law Finder

Florida's dependency statutes, court rules and DCF operating procedures, with the appellate opinions that apply them

data.robertlathamesq.org · All tools

Before you use this site

This site aggregates legal authorities from a variety of public sources. It is AI and human reviewed. Text processing errors can occur. Always check the information here against the official linked source.

This site is publicly available. Use for general research only. Do not submit confidential or identifiable case information.

I don't agree: show the official sources

Department of Children & Families v. J.M.B.119 So. 3d 1292 (Fla. 4th DCA 2013) · 4D13-773

Court
4th DCA
Decided
2013-09-04
Case
Dependency
Appellant
DCF
County
Palm Beach

Certiorari / writ granted Certiorari granted, quashing an overbroad order requiring DCF to give the attorney ad litem other children's confidential psychiatric referral records.

Issues
Discovery, subpoenas & compelled examinations, Certiorari: departure from the essential requirements of law

Summary, issues, facts, outcome, and appellant were extracted automatically from the opinion. Check the opinion itself before relying on them.

On CourtListener
PER CURIAM.

The Department of Children and Families (the “Department”) seeks certiorari review of a non-final discovery order. We grant the petition and quash the order. Dep’t of Children & Family Servs. v. I.C., 742 So.2d 401, 405 (Fla. 4th DCA 1999). In doing so, we acknowledge respondent’s limited concession, but decline to construe the order as requiring in camera production as it is clear in this case that the order required dissemination of the records. Cf. id.

The trial court issued the order under review while considering a suitability assessment associated with a specific dependent child. During the hearing, the court heard about delay between the child’s referral for psychiatric evaluation and the actual assessment. The court expressed frustration and then ordered the Department to produce to the attorney ad litem

[a]ll referrals, information, documentation or records made in the 30 days preceding this Order for a Palm Beach County dependent child to receive a psychiatric evaluation and/or assessment. Any and all information, documentation or records regarding the appointment made as a result of a referral for a psychiatric evaluation and/or assessment made in the preceding 30 days.

First, any such discovery should be reviewed in camera given the confidential nature of the children’s information. Id. Second, the production as ordered is too broad. Id. Consequently, we grant the petition and quash that portion of the order.1

Petition for writ of certioran granted.

WARNER, TAYLOR and LEVINE, JJ., concur.

. The Department contested only the portion of the order requiring it to release confidential records of children who are not parties to the case below. It noted that the dependent child’s placement rendered moot any other issues.

Opinion text: CourtListener, Free Law Project. Not an official reporter; check the court's version before citing.